From now until the 2025 NFL Draft, we will scout and create profiles for as many prospects as possible, examining their strengths, weaknesses, and what they can bring to an NFL franchise. These players could be potential top 10 picks, down to Day 3 selections, and priority undrafted free agents. Today, a scouting report on Laurier (Canada) QB Taylor Elgersma.
#13 Taylor Elgersma/QB Laurier – 6043, 216 pounds (Fifth-Year Senior)
| Player | Ht/Wt | Hand Size | Arm Length | Wingspan |
| Taylor Elgersma | 6043/216 | 9 1/2 | 32 1/2 | 77 1/4 |
| 40-Yard Dash | 10-Yard Dash | Short Shuttle | 3-Cone | |
| 4.53 | 1.60 | N/A | N/A | |
| Broad Jump | Vertical | Bench Press | ||
| 9’9″ | 32.5 | N/A |
The Good
– Great deep-ball accuracy
– Good accuracy on the move
– Displays good arm talent with consistent three-level accuracy
– Throws digs with great precision
– Throws with good anticipation
– Pushes the ball with high aggressiveness
– Good with RPOs
The Bad
– Game will struggle to translate to next level
– Played against low-level competition
– Defenses he played against had low awareness
– Statue in the pocket
– Cannot avoid sacks
– Bad pocket awareness
– Struggles to identify blitzes
– Loses confidence versus pressure
– Puts the ball in dangerous spots versus pressure
– Fumbles the ball versus pressure
– Average athletic ability
– Does not provide much positive rushing ability
– Weak arm strength, struggles throwing from hash to field
Bio
– 33 games started across four years at Laurier in Waterloo, Canada
– 2024: completed 275 passes for 4,011 yards, 34 touchdowns, and 10 interceptions. Also rushed 44 times for 229 yards and six touchdowns
– Won the Hec Crighton Award, given to the most outstanding player Canadian football player in U Sports
– Competed in the 2025 Senior Bowl
– 2023: completed 274 passes for 3,482 yards, 25 touchdowns, and eight interceptions. Rushed 35 times for 182 yards and 10 touchdowns
– Named the OUA MVP
– Second-team All-Canadian selection
– 2022: completed 178 yards for 2,141 yards, 15 touchdowns, and nine interceptions. Rushed 32 times for 125 yards and one touchdown
– Attended Oakridge Secondary School in London, Ontario, where he also played hockey
– Michael Faulds, his head coach, would have to call Elgersma and tell him to take some breaks as he is always focused on football
Tape Breakdown
Taylor Elgersma is a legend in the U Sports League of Canada, winning the Heisman Trophy equivalent in 2024. However, the difference in play style between Canada and the United States will be hard for him to overcome.
Elgersma’s arm talent is impressive and is the reason he received an invite to the 2025 Senior Bowl. He displays good accuracy to all three levels of the field, and deep accuracy is the best part of his game. He has no trouble pushing the ball downfield, and when he does, he throws with perfect accuracy, leading to explosive plays.
Elgersma does a good job layering throws over the linebackers’ heads, especially when throwing dig routes. His favorite concept is dagger, which usually ends up in an explosive play due to his exceptional deep-ball accuracy. When throwing corner routes, he puts great touch on the ball, sailing it over defenders’ heads and dropping it in the receiver’s bucket.
There is no denying Elgersma’s ability to throw with good accuracy in a clean pocket, but it worries me when there is pressure in the pocket, as his awareness needs a lot of work. He can move around the pocket into defenders, causing sacks. He has a lot of trouble identifying when a blitz is coming and only takes notice when he is about to be taken down. This results in him fumbling the ball from his blindside.
His rushing ability is average, and Elgersma has no burst to get ahead of a defender. He does not avoid sacks, which highlights his average athletic ability. On this play, he does not sense obvious pressure at the line of scrimmage and cannot avoid the sack because he realizes it too late.
When Elgersma does get the ball out against pressure, he loses a lot of confidence and puts the ball in dangerous spots. You can see him in the film starting to hesitate when under duress, and that big gunslinger we see when he is in a clean pocket disappears. He always looks toward the closest receiver option when there is pressure because he cannot avoid a sack and tries to create something out of the pocket. On this play, a dangerous throw could have resulted in an interception, but the receiver made a play to knock it down.
While his accuracy is the best part of his game, Elgersma’s arm strength is lacking, and when he throws across the field, the ball floats. That limits YAC opportunities and gives defenses time to flow to the ball. He struggles when he must get through his progressions and throw the ball from the hash to the field, where a fast defensive back can intercept the floating ball.
Conclusion
Taylor Elgersma is an interesting prospect because of his pedigree in Canada and the question of how it will translate to the NFL. The competition he played against was not impressive, and the defenses played with low awareness and not great athletes. His accuracy is extremely impressive, and I like his ability to process information in a clean pocket. However, his pocket awareness, struggles under pressure, and weaker arm are concerns for his NFL future. My comp for him is Connor Cook.
Projection: Late Day 3
Depot Draft Grade: 6.3 – 6th/7th Round (End of Roster/Practice Squad)
Games Watched: vs Queens (2024), at Bishops (2024), vs Laval (2024)
